Don’t Make “Assumptions”
Every month, I get this medical newsletter from a prestigious medical society. This month, they included a new section:
The Asian-American Patient
For some reason, one Dr. Gilbert Liu is holding a “workshop” in order to teach doctors about “ethnic-specific versus pan-Asian dimensions of Asian American identity, highlighting the roles and contributions of Asian Americans in the United States.” One of the goals of this workshop is to promote “social justice.”
First of all, I have never met Dr. Liu. So there is no way he can examine my “ethnic-specific versus pan-Asian dimensions.”
Second of all, for someone who is telling people not to make “assumptions,” he is pretty presumptious.
I would hope that doctors’ continued medical education is helpful for all cultures, not just those of “Asian-Americans.” People can make all sorts of assumptions about anyone based on race, whether they’re white, Asian, black, or anywhere in between. I personally don’t care! I just hope that if one has chosen to be a physician, one gives them the best health care one can offer, regardless of one’s patients’ cultures.
I expect my patients to teach me about their individual cultures. I don’t expect to get that information from a “workshop.”
One of my good friends made waffles with me one morning, and he spread peanut butter and maple syrup on them. I had never heard of such a thing, and I told him so. He said, “Americans all eat waffles this way.” I said, “I grew up here, and I have never heard of eating waffles with peanut butter and syrup.” But I tried it, and I liked it!
Later, he told his mom about my American waffle cultural knowledge deficit. And his mom told him, “Well, we’re the only family in San Marcos that does that, that I know of.”
Culture is very specific.
You can’t know till you ask.